Oregon has 55 4 or 5 star recruits
- Thread starter longtimer
- Start date
ssckelley
Well-Known Member
Gives me a little hope that it could happen some day at Iowa.
I think CIgnetti is some sort of God Damned Warlock. The job he has done with this team is unprecedented. By the recruiting stars, Indiana has roughly the same talent as Tulane. By performance, they are the most dominant team in the country by a mile. How does he do this?
Sure, but something like this has never happened before, so what are the odds of it happening again in our lifetime, and coincidentally happening to our favorite team?
Counterpoint: maybe we cannot compare this day and age to the history of CFB, as NIL has upended everything.
Counter-counterpoint: we do not have a Mark Cuban.
ssckelley
Well-Known Member
You know we came dang close this past season. All we needed was a couple of breaks in those 4 losses. We proved we could compete with Indiana, I was at that game and we should have won.
Absolutely, our current approach of incrementalism is moving us in the right direction. I think we have smart people who are adapting to the current environment. I think the fact they have always run things like a "pro" team have prepared them well for this era of professional-amateurism. I think they have a tremendous culture, and I think they could easily find their way into the CFP and win a game.
I just don't think they are going to transform into the most dominant teams in CFB overnight, like Indiana did. I also don't think there is another Cignetti out there, I believe he broke the mold. I do think his success will result in some much deserved opportunities for really talented lower-level coaches, and hopefully we can break out of the P4-retread cycle. I just think what happened at Indiana is NOT going to be repeatable, though undoubtedly many teams will try.
Seth53
Well-Known Member
^^Agreed.^^
I was there also and we had the game won. Make a FG. Convert an easy screen pass...and we win.
I consider this one of the best Iowa teams, talent wise, in a decade if not longer...although the final record might not indicate it. But if one does some actual research, it bears out.
Side note...we came oh-so-close to the CFP (before they watered down the acceptance pool) when we lost that heart-breaker to MSU at Lucas Oil. I was at that one too.
99topdawg
Well-Known Member
Stars from HS is an even more overrated stat than ever. When schools can get late blooming 2/3 star players that have developed into studs, they essentially are now 4 and 5 star players. It doesn't matter what they were 2, 3, or 4 years ago. In the NFL, outside of Brady and Purdy, they never talk about what round someone was drafted in.
MelroseHawkins
Well-Known Member
I heard that to. I couldn't believe it.
I was in North endzone. Gronowski doesn’t go down and I think we score. Clearly we gave them tough game. I wasn’t overly impressed with them. Same thing with Oregon. And if Iowa state doesn’t catch that tipped pass. Geesh. So close
ssckelley
Well-Known Member
North end zone is where my seats are as well, but up in the nose bleeds.
AreWeThereYet
Well-Known Member
It is what it is. Gronowski was struggling with accuracy, had limited practice time with the team, and was working his way back from what amounts to six months layoff from practicing. Likewise, the coaching staff struggled with finding things that worked for Gronowski, given his limitations.
Pretty sure that was Hank Brown. Gronowski had gone out with the injured knee in that game. Which is another thing that makes you think we would've won the game had he not gotten injured. But Hank simply missed the throw, unfortunately.